Fibre Cement vs. Engineered Wood: Which Siding Is Better for YOUR Project?

Siding Showdown: Fibre Cement vs. Engineered Wood

When homeowners or contractors are specifying siding for their projects, two products dominate the conversation: fibre cement and engineered wood. Both offer durability, modern aesthetics, and are relatively cost-effective—but each has its own strengths depending on project goals and installation conditions.

At White Glove Contracting, we can offer support to help you decide which product is right for you - here’s a breakdown to help you make the right choice.

Fibre Cement Siding (e.g., James Hardie)

Pros:

• Fire-rated and non-combustible: A major plus for meeting BCBC fire safety requirements.

• Low maintenance: Resistant to rot, insects, and UV damage with minimal upkeep.

• Stable in extreme temperatures: Holds shape in freeze-thaw cycles.

• Curb appeal: Offers wood-look finishes and smooth panel systems in contemporary colors.

Cons:

• Heavy material: Requires more labor and equipment during installation.

• Brittle edges: Can chip or crack if mishandled.

• Higher install cost: Especially when scaffolding is involved.

Engineered Wood Siding (e.g., LP SmartSide)

Pros:

• Lightweight and fast to install: Less labor-intensive, saving time on larger buildings.

• Impact-resistant: Resists dings and cracks better than cement products.

• Pre-finished options: Reduce finishing work and weather exposure on site.

• Cost-effective: Lower install costs due to speed and handling.

Cons:

• Combustibility: May require specific assemblies to meet fire code.

• Higher maintenance over time: Especially in shaded or damp environments.

MATERIAL + Labour Cost Comparison

Fibre cement board - higher material cost and heavier so more labour intensive to install

Engineered wood - more cost-effective than fibre cement with a less labor intensive installation process

Ultimately you will see a slight price difference between the two with fibre cement being the more costly option although the impact on the total cost will be minor

White Glove’s Verdict

If your project is in a high-density area or needs a 1- or 2-hour fire rating, fibre cement is likely your best bet. For low-rise wood-frame construction, engineered wood offers serious speed and aesthetic value without sacrificing durability—especially when paired with a rainscreen and exterior insulation.

We work closely with our clients to tailor siding systems to their performance and budget needs. Whether it’s a HardiePanel or an LP SmartSide lap system, we ensure proper detailing, flashing, and bug screen protection every time.

Want to learn more or chat about your next project? Contact us today.